Same delays. Different law. Different answer.
Research by Charles Gava
Set up an employer delay and a contractor delay on the programme below. Each legal approach then decides how much extra time the contractor gets, how much of it is paid, and how much the contractor carries as its own delay.
1 · The facts on the programme
Drag a bar to move it. Drag its right edge to change its length. Arrow keys work too.2 · What the delays did to completion
3 · Seven legal answers to the same facts
Adjust the Scottish (City Inn) assumptions
4 · Where the choice of law matters
Each point is a different employer delay: when it starts (left to right) and how long it lasts (bottom to top). Everything else stays as set above.
Darker means the approaches disagree by more days. Pale means the law you pick makes little difference.
The orange band marks when the contractor's delay is running. The ring is your current employer delay. Click the map to move it.
How each answer is worked out
The programme is treated as a causal model. For any combination of the two delays it gives the delay to completion against the as-planned date. Each legal approach is then a rule applied to the same three numbers: the delay the employer's event would cause alone, the contractor's alone, and both together.
- Actual-delay test: an employer delay counts only if it causes actual delay to completion as then scheduled (Adyard [2011] EWHC 848 (Comm) paras 279–299; Saga Cruises [2016] EWHC 1875 (Comm) para 251). If it does, the contractor's concurrent delay does not reduce the extension (Malmaison; Walter Lilly [2012] EWHC 1773 (TCC) para 370; Thomas Barnes [2022] EWHC 2598 (TCC) paras 118 and 148). This is the only rule here that matches all five English cases. It was written after reading those judgments, so the match shows consistency, not independent prediction.
- As-planned impact: impacts the employer's delay on the as-planned programme and ignores timing. Adyard (para 264) and Saga (para 249) reject this kind of theoretical delay.
- Overlapping windows: any delays whose effects overlap in time are concurrent. A broad reading of the “felt at the same time” wording in Adyard para 279.
- Strict sequence: only delays that start on the same day are concurrent. Otherwise a later employer delay earns time only for the delay it adds on top. Some commentators attribute this to Adyard, but the judgment states the test above.
- NEC4 (clause 63.5, reading to verify): each compensation event is assessed prospectively against the programme at the time, and time and money go together.
- City Inn [2010] CSIH 68 (Scotland): a dominant cause takes the period. Otherwise the shared days are apportioned by relative culpability.
- Cyden-style clause (North Midland v Cyden Homes [2018] EWCA Civ 1744): the contract excludes concurrent delay, so only days the employer alone caused count. This gives the same number as a but-for test.
- Money under every approach follows only days that would not have been lost but for the employer (Keating 9-105, adopted in Thomas Barnes para 118).
The case presets are stylised two-path reconstructions. The dates and figures for Adyard, Saga and Thomas Barnes come from the judgments, read on the National Archives' Find Case Law service. Where a delay length is a party's claim or is worked back from the outcome, the preset note says so. Malmaison and Cyden use illustrative figures. City Inn is illustrative and its judgment text has not yet been checked. This is a research tool, not legal advice. The contract always governs.
How the law on concurrent delay got here
Research by Charles Gava
Twenty-five years of English and Scottish decisions, the SCL Protocol and the standard forms. Each entry shows what it decided, which rule it supports, and how carefully it has been checked.
Three jurisdictions on one line
Three phases
Malmaison gives the contractor time despite its own concurrent delay. Royal Brompton insists the employer event must actually affect completion. The SCL Protocol's first edition takes a broad view.
Scotland apportions where no cause is dominant (City Inn). England refuses (Walter Lilly) and tightens the test: both causes must actually delay completion, felt at the same time (Adyard, Saga).
The 2017 forms either leave concurrency to the parties (FIDIC 8.5) or price it prospectively (NEC4). Cyden upholds a clause that excludes it. Thomas Barnes separates 119 days of time from 27 days of money.